Simpler Way To Hold Family Investments
Originally posted to Forbes.com
Family Investments
If you’re like many other investors you may have lots of family non-qualified (non-retirement) accounts. You have accounts, your spouse has accounts, your kids have accounts, your family trusts each have an account, and so on. To simplify the replication of many small investment accounts many people create a family partnership or limited liability company (LLC) or family partnership to consolidate all those family investment accounts into one.
It is common to create trusts as part of an estate plan. Trusts might include revocable trusts (e.g. one for each spouse) to avoid probate, one or two life insurance trusts, perhaps after the death of one spouse a family or marital trust or both. It can be convenient to consolidate investment assets from these trusts and even family members into an entity, such as a LLC so that there can be one investment account for the overall family relationship instead of separate investment accounts for every person and family trust. That can be a simplification. It can also facilitate an account being over a certain dollar figure to qualify for investment management fee discounts or break points, or aggregate the account to a level where new investment options become available. It also just may be easier. Yes, each trust or family entity might still need to have its own checking account, but it may eliminate any replication of investment accounts. Your investment adviser might really appreciate this to as they might then have one bucket of assets to allocate instead of 5, 10 or more.
In short, using an investment LLC structure can simplify investment management, permit coordinated oversight and reduce the administrative complexities and costs of maintaining separate accounts.
But there is a possible drawback to this otherwise simplifying technique. Generally, LLC with several members will be treated as a partnership for income tax purposes and will thus have to file a partnership income tax return. Some people will find the cost and complexity of that step a detraction from what might otherwise be a useful simplification technique of an LLC.
Consolidation Has a Hidden Cost
There is a solution to avoid the tax filing so you can consolidate investment accounts without the added annual hassle and cost of another tax return. But most people, and even many professional advisers, don’t know about it. How to do just that is the discussed below.
What can be done about this recurring drawback. The rule is that a domestic (meaning US not foreign) LLC with two or more members is ordinarily classified as a partnership for federal income tax purposes unless it elects otherwise. That commonly means that an annual partnership income tax return, Form 1065, Schedules K-1 and related state filings, are required. This is true even when the entity merely holds marketable securities and earns interest and dividends. For a simple investment entity, the preparation fees and administrative work may be disproportionate to the entity’s activity.
For some of these investment arrangements, Internal Revenue Code Section 761(a) offers a potential way out. A qualifying unincorporated organization, like an LLC or partnership, may elect to be excluded from the partnership income tax rules (Subchapter K of the Internal Revenue Code). If the exclusion from partnership tax is valid and remains effective, the members of the LLC (or partners in a partnership) instead report their respective shares of income and other tax items directly on their own personal income tax returns (Form 1040 for individuals and Form 1041 for trusts), rather than having the LLC compute partnership taxable income and file recurring partnership returns. The extra entity tax filing is avoided entirely at the federal level.
Who May Qualify?
The election is not available merely because the LLC or partnership entity is passive which means that it holds investments and doesn’t operate a business. It also doesn’t matter that whatever assets the LLC has are easy to account for so that the owners can readily report the income instead. For an investment arrangement to qualify the Treasury Regulations, Section 1.761-2, require that the participants own the investment property as co-owners, retain the right separately to take or dispose of their shares (membership or partnership interest in the entity), and not actively conduct business. They also cannot irrevocably authorize a representative to purchase, sell or exchange the entity property. Each member must be able to compute his, her or its income without the organization first computing partnership taxable income. I.R.C. §761(a); Treas. Reg. §1.761-2(a)(1)-(2).
A family LLC holding cash, Treasury obligations, certificates of deposit, and a portfolio of securities, may be a candidate, but the governing documents (LLC operating agreement or partnership’s partnership agreement), and the actual operations of the entity must comply with the rules. Broad manager powers, trading activity, restrictions inconsistent with separate ownership, special partnership allocations, disproportionate economic interest, and other factors, may prevent the LLC qualifying for the election.
Why Wealth Advisers Should Care
You should review the potential benefits of consolidating accounts with their wealth adviser as they may be the first professional to see the opportunity.
- How many family individual and trust accounts are there?
- Would consolidating investment components of those accounts offer investment simplification or other advantages?
- If an LLC (or partnership) had previously been set up by an estate planning attorney, perhaps for valuation discounts or other purposes, has that triggered a partnership tax filing?
- Do account registrations reveal that several non-grantor trusts own one LLC, while the portfolio produces easily traceable interest, dividends and gains.
Your adviser can flag the possible benefits of using an investment LLC (or opting out of partnership taxation if you already have such an entity) for review by your attorney and CPA. A valid election can eliminate recurring federal partnership-return preparation and may simplify the delivery of tax information to the trusts. But, yes, it’s important to have an attorney and CPA confirm that there are no issues and that the LLC has the appropriate legal documents.
Remember, this is a tax filing (compliance) simplification, not a tax-saving technique. The income each member reports does not change or disappear. Each member or family trust must report its share directly and maintain adequate basis, holding-period and transaction records. The potential savings arise from avoiding an unnecessary entity-level computation and return, not from changing the amount or character of the income. Other savings and benefits may arise from simplifying family investment accounts that have grown in number.
Making the “Election” to Avoid Federal Partnership Tax Filings
Avoiding partnership tax filings is accomplished by filing a partnership tax return that has a statement that the partnership is choosing (electing) not to be taxed as a partnership. Yes, that sounds odd, that you have to file a partnership return in order not to file a partnership return. But that is our Alice in Wonderland tax world.
The election (on the one partnership tax return your LLC or partnership must file to get out of all of this) is made no later than the due date, including extensions, for the partnership return for the first tax year for which exclusion is desired. The LLC or partnership files a properly executed partnership tax return, Form 1065, with a statement (in tax jargon, an “election”) attached providing the information to meet the tax law requirements to opt out. Importantly, the tax regulations say that, in lieu of the information otherwise required by Form 1065 and its instructions, the filing need contain only specified identifying and election information. It does not require the LLC to report its interest, dividends, deductions or partner allocations on that election return, although some recommend that for the tax return opting out income for that year be indicated.
While this is a pretty simple form you might choose to have a professional tax preparer handle the filing since the confirmation that the requirements have in fact been met may be nuanced. The return will include the LLC’s name, address and other basic identifying information, checking a box on the face of the return (see below) and notating that the return reflects opting out of partnership tax status.
As noted above, a statement must be attached that contains all of the information required under the tax laws:
(1) the names, addresses and taxpayer identification numbers of all members or owners;
(2) a statement that the organization qualifies under the applicable portions of Treasury Regulation Section 1.761-2(a);
(3) a statement that all members elect to opt out of the partnership tax rules under Subchapter K of the Internal Revenue Code; and
(4) a statement identifying where a copy of the governing agreement (operating agreement for an LLC and a partnership agreement if the entity is a partnership) is available, from whom its terms may be obtained.
Boxes to Check (Or Not!)
Form 1065 itself does not contain a box to check that the entity is electing out (in tax jargon a “checkbox”). There simply is no box to check indicating that the return is for the purpose of electing under Section 761(a) not to be taxed as a partnership (why should it be easy?).
- A reasonable disclosure practice is to check the box for “Initial return” if this is the entity’s first Form 1065 (which if you form a new LLC for this planning technique it will be).
- Even though no further partnership tax returns will be filed don’t check the box that this is a “Final Return” because the state-law entity continues. In other words, while the LLC or partnership won’t be treated as a partnership for federal income tax purposes the entity still exists under state law.
- Finally, use the box labeled “Other” to state: “Election under IRC §761(a) to be excluded from Subchapter K.” This checkbox treatment is a practical filing recommendation, not an express instruction in the regulation. The return should be timely filed and signed. Advisers should not confuse this election with the separate election out of the centralized partnership audit regime.
Sample Election Statement
Below is a sample of language that might be used to create the statement that you (or better, your CPA) would attach to this special tax filing:
“Pursuant to Internal Revenue Code §761(a) and Treasury Regulation §1.761-2, all members of [LLC NAME], EIN [NUMBER], elect to exclude the organization from all provisions of Subchapter K beginning with the taxable year ending [DATE]. The organization is used solely for investment purposes and not for the active conduct of a business. It qualifies under Treasury Regulation §1.761-2(a)(1) and (a)(2), and each member can determine its share of income, gain, loss, deduction and credit without computing partnership taxable income. The names, addresses and taxpayer identification numbers of all members are listed below. A copy of the operating agreement is available from [NAME AND ADDRESS].”
You (or better your attorney) should tailor the above sample statement to the facts of your situation, and include the required member information.
Once effective, the election generally remains irrevocable while the organization continues to qualify, unless the IRS approves the entity’s revocation of the election out of partnership tax reporting.
Checklist for Your Attorney
Even though overall this is a pretty simple process the following are points you should have your attorney review. Most of these are addressed in the governing document of the entity (operating agreement for an LLC or partnership agreement for a partnership):
- Confirm that the entity is an unincorporated organization and is not treated as a corporation for federal tax purposes.
- Limit the stated purpose and actual activity of the entity, both in practice and in the egal documents, to investment, not an active trade or business.
- Confirm that the members are treated as co-owners of the investment property (e.g. the securities account) in the entity documents.
- Preserve each member’s right separately to take or dispose of its share of acquired or retained property.
- Avoid special allocations, preferred returns, waterfalls or other economics that require partnership-level taxable-income calculations.
- Review manager and investment-adviser authority.
- Ensure each owner (e.g. individual or trust) can determine and report its share of every item directly from reliable books, brokerage statements and transaction records.
- Require operations to remain consistent with the agreement and the election, including pro rata ownership and reporting.
- Address what happens if the entity begins a business, changes investments, admits a member or otherwise ceases to qualify.
- Coordinate federal and state filings before assuming that the federal election eliminates every state return or entity-level fee.
The Adviser’s Practical Role
Using an entity, like an LLC and the special election to avoid a tax filing for that entity can be a valuable housekeeping tool for the right family investment arrangement. The wealth adviser can identify candidate entities, help produce member-level account data and encourage a coordinated review by tax counsel and the return preparer. Used carefully, the election may preserve the benefits of consolidated investment management while reducing recurring compliance expense and administrative burden.
